Get free alertsFree alerts

How price is scored in public tenders

Last reviewed 20 October 2026. General guidance, not legal advice.

On this page (8 parts)
  1. Most advantageous, not cheapest
  2. Reading the weightings
  3. How price marks are worked out
  4. Abnormally low tenders
  5. Pricing to score without losing money
  6. After the result
  7. Frequently asked questions
  8. Sources

Many small firms assume the cheapest bid wins a public contract, and either cut their price to the bone or do not bid at all. Neither is a good plan. Under the Procurement Act 2023 buyers award contracts to the "most advantageous tender", assessed against criteria they publish in advance, and for most trades and facilities contracts that means price and quality together. This guide explains how price marks are worked out and what that means for your pricing.

Key points

Most advantageous, not cheapest

Section 19 of the Act says a buyer may award a contract to the supplier that submits the most advantageous tender. The Cabinet Office guidance on assessing competitive tenders explains that this replaced "most economically advantageous tender" and that "tenders do not have to be awarded on the basis of lowest price/cost". Price can still be the only criterion, but the guidance says buyers must consider their other duties under the Act first.

Reading the weightings

Under section 23, award criteria must relate to the subject matter of the contract and be "sufficiently clear, measurable and specific". Where there is more than one criterion, the buyer must set out their relative importance, for example as a percentage, by ranking them, or by describing them another way. It must also say whether failing a criterion would disqualify a tender, which is how minimum quality scores work.

Price is not always a single number. When the London Borough of Merton awarded a school cleaning contract in 2022 (under the old rules), its published report set out this split (Merton Council):

Element Weighting
Price: total cost 15%
Price: total hours against benchmark 15%
Price: hourly cost 15%
Price: ratio of wage cost to charge 7.5%
Price: variation rates 5%
Price: ancillary service charges 2.5%
Quality (three criteria) 35%
Social value 5%

Here a bid that is cheap because it under-resources the work can lose marks within the price section itself.

Central government buyers must give social value at least 10% of the total score (or an equivalent) on above-threshold procurements started on or after 1 October 2025, under PPN 002. For their procurements worth £1 million or more started on or after 1 January 2027, PPN 026 sets a minimum of 10%, or 20% from £5 million. Other buyers set their own weighting. See social value in public contracts.

How price marks are worked out

The tender documents should explain the formula. A common approach is relative scoring, where each price is compared with the lowest. One published tender from 2016 put it like this: "Price will be 60 x (lowest priced technically compliant bid divided by tender price)" (Contracts Finder).

Here is how that works on a contract weighted 60% quality and 40% price, with three bidders:

Bidder Price Price score (out of 40) Quality score (out of 60) Total
A £80,000 40.0 39.0 79.0
B £100,000 32.0 51.0 83.0
C £120,000 26.7 51.0 77.7

Bidder B is 25% dearer than A but wins, because its quality answers scored 12 marks higher and it lost only 8 on price. With a 70% price weighting, A would have won. That is why the weighting matters so much.

Other methods you may see:

The government's guidance tells buyers to test scenarios and be aware of "the potential negative impacts on value for money of the use of relative scoring mechanisms". Relative scoring means your price score depends on what others bid, so you cannot know it in advance. You can still model it: estimate a likely low bid, for example from the value in the previous contract award notice, and see how many quality marks you would need to beat it.

Abnormally low tenders

Under section 19, a buyer may disregard a tender that offers a price it considers abnormally low. Before it does, it must tell the supplier and give it a reasonable opportunity to show it can perform the contract at that price. If the supplier satisfies the buyer, the tender cannot be disregarded on that ground.

The guidance notes that a low price can have legitimate reasons, such as efficiencies or economies of scale, and less acceptable ones, such as inaccuracies in cost modelling or unlawful practices. For labour-heavy work like cleaning, security and grounds, buyers often look closely at whether a price covers the hours in the specification at lawful wage rates, plus any staff transferring under TUPE (see TUPE in cleaning and FM contracts).

Keep your pricing workings for every bid (hours, rates, on-costs, materials, travel, overheads and margin) so you can answer quickly if asked to justify your price.

Pricing to score without losing money

  1. Build your price from the bottom up, from the specification and your real costs, as set out in how to write a tender.
  2. Work out what quality is worth. On a 60/40 contract, quality carries half as much weight again as price, so a few extra quality marks can outweigh a noticeably higher price. Time spent on quality answers is often a better investment than a lower price.
  3. Check the previous contract's value. Award notices show the value of the previous contract, which helps you judge whether your price is in the right range.
  4. Do not buy the contract. A price you cannot deliver at risks being questioned as abnormally low and, if you win, years of losses.
  5. Fill in the pricing schedule exactly as instructed. Errors and missing rates can lead to a bid being marked down or excluded.

After the result

On above-threshold contracts under the Act, each bidder whose tender was assessed must receive an assessment summary before the contract award notice is published. According to the assessment summaries guidance, it gives your score for each criterion and, if you lost, the winning tender's assessment too. Compare the scores to see whether you lost on cost or on content. Summaries are not required on framework call-offs or smaller contracts, but you can still ask for feedback.

Frequently asked questions

Does the lowest price always win a public contract?

No. Contracts are awarded to the most advantageous tender against published criteria. The lowest price wins only if price is the sole criterion, or if its price advantage outweighs other bidders' quality scores.

Can a buyer reject my bid for being too cheap?

Only after telling you it considers the price abnormally low and giving you a reasonable chance to show you can deliver at that price.

Is it worth bidding low to get a foot in the door?

Only if the price still covers your costs. A loss-making contract ties up your staff and cash for its whole term, and a price that looks unrealistic can be questioned as abnormally low.

BidTrowel's contract pages show how bids will be scored where the notice gives the weightings, so you can see the price and quality split before you open the documents.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Always follow the evaluation method set out in the tender documents.

Sources

Get public contracts that fit your firm by email. Free: every weekday for your first two weeks, then Mondays when there are new matches.

Get free alerts