Why tenders get rejected, and how to avoid it
On this page (6 parts)
This guide is for owners of small trades and facilities firms who want to stop losing tenders for avoidable reasons. It explains why bids are thrown out or score badly, which points are rules under the Procurement Act 2023 and which are good practice, and what information you get after the decision.
Key points
- Under the Act a buyer must disregard a tender from a supplier that fails the conditions of participation, and may disregard one that breaks a procedural requirement, such as being late or over the word count.
- Before rejecting a price as abnormally low, the buyer must tell you and give you a reasonable opportunity to show you can do the work for that price.
- Buyers cannot demand that contract insurance is in place before award, but they can ask for evidence you will have it from the start of the contract.
- For above-threshold contracts awarded after a competitive tender, every supplier whose tender was assessed gets an assessment summary with its scores and the winner's, followed, for most contracts, by a standstill period of at least eight working days.
- Lower-value (below-threshold) contracts carry no legal duty to give an assessment summary or observe a standstill period, so asking for feedback matters even more.
First, check which rules apply
The Procurement Act 2023 applies to procurements started on or after 24 February 2025 in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. Procurements started before then continue under the old rules (mainly the Public Contracts Regulations 2015). Devolved Scottish public bodies, such as councils, follow Scottish legislation instead, including the Procurement Reform (Scotland) Act 2014 and the Public Contracts (Scotland) Regulations 2015. Wales uses the Act but with some differences set by Welsh regulations and guidance.
Most of the detailed rules below apply to "public contracts", meaning contracts above the value thresholds. Lower-value "below-threshold" contracts are covered by a much lighter set of rules in Part 6 of the Act. One rule worth knowing there: for most below-threshold contracts the buyer cannot use a separate suitability stage (such as a questionnaire on experience or accounts) to cut the number of suppliers allowed to tender. Our guide to the Procurement Act for small suppliers covers thresholds and procedures.
Reasons a bid is thrown out
Missing the deadline
The Act lets a buyer disregard any tender that breaches a procedural requirement set out in the tender notice or tender documents. The government's guidance gives a late tender as an example. Note the word is "may", not "must", so the buyer has discretion. But time limits must be the same for every supplier and buyers must treat suppliers the same unless a difference justifies otherwise, so do not plan on that discretion being used for you.
Good practice: upload at least a day early, check the deadline time as well as the date, and keep the portal's submission receipt.
Breaking the instructions
Word limits and other instructions in the tender documents, such as page limits or file formats, can be procedural requirements too. The guidance names a tender that is "over the prescribed word count" as something a buyer may disregard, and it encourages buyers to say up front which requirements could lead to rejection. Read the instructions to tenderers before you write anything, not after.
Failing a pass/fail question or a condition of participation
Conditions of participation test whether you can do the job: legal and financial capacity, or technical ability. If you do not meet them, the buyer must disregard your tender. Award criteria can also include pass/fail tests, as long as the buyer has said in its assessment method that failing one disqualifies the tender. Missing mandatory documents and information often falls under these headings, and the Act defines a procedural requirement as including a requirement to provide information.
The Act limits what buyers can ask for. Conditions must be proportionate to the contract. Buyers cannot require audited accounts from a firm that is not legally required to have them audited, cannot require a contract with a particular authority as experience, and must accept equivalents to any named qualification. You can also rely on a partner or sub-contractor to meet a condition if you have binding arrangements in place. See our guides to insurance and turnover requirements and accreditations by trade.
Exclusion grounds and the debarment list
The Act sets out mandatory exclusion grounds (Schedule 6) and discretionary ones (Schedule 7). Mandatory grounds are mainly serious offences such as fraud, bribery, theft, slavery, tax offences and organised crime. Discretionary grounds include insolvency, labour market and environmental misconduct, professional misconduct, acting improperly in a procurement, and breach of contract or poor performance.
The breach of contract ground matters for trades firms. It can apply where a contract with a public authority was terminated, damages were awarded or a settlement was reached, or where you did not perform to the authority's satisfaction, were given a proper opportunity to improve and failed to.
A ground only leads to exclusion if the buyer considers the circumstances are continuing or likely to happen again. The buyer must give you a reasonable opportunity to make representations and provide evidence first, and it can take into account steps you have taken, such as changing management or putting procedures and training in place. Time limits apply: for breach of contract and poor performance, the buyer must ignore events it knew (or should reasonably have known) about more than three years ago, and for most other grounds the limit is five years. The grounds can also apply through people connected to your firm (such as directors or a parent company) and sub-contractors you rely on to meet the conditions. If the problem is a sub-contractor you rely on, you must be given the chance to replace them.
Ministers also keep a central debarment list, published on GOV.UK, and buyers must check it in each procurement.
Good practice: declare honestly and fully. If you fail to provide information requested about connected persons or sub-contractors, or give incomplete or misleading information, the buyer must treat you as excluded from that award.
Not registered on the Central Digital Platform
Under the Act, buyers must get confirmation that you have registered on the Central Digital Platform and shared your core supplier information. In a competitive tender, the end of the tendering period is the deadline for that. Winners of notifiable below-threshold contracts (from £12,000 including VAT for central government buyers and £30,000 including VAT for other buyers) must also be registered (in England since 1 April 2026). Register well before you need to: see our Central Digital Platform registration guide.
An abnormally low price
A buyer may disregard a tender whose price it considers abnormally low. Before doing so it must tell you it thinks the price is abnormally low and give you a reasonable opportunity to show you can perform the contract for that price. If you satisfy the buyer, it cannot reject the tender on that ground. The guidance notes a low price might come from genuine efficiencies, or from mistakes in cost modelling.
Good practice: keep your price build-up (labour hours, wage rates, materials, travel, overheads) so you can answer quickly if asked.
Conflicts of interest
Buyers must identify and manage conflicts of interest, such as an evaluator who owns shares in a bidder. If a conflict gives a supplier an unfair advantage that cannot be avoided, or the supplier refuses reasonable steps the buyer requires, the buyer must exclude that supplier. Separately, a supplier that accesses confidential information or unduly influences the buyer's decision must be excluded where that gives it an unfair advantage that cannot be avoided any other way (the buyer must let it make representations first). If you have a link to someone at the buyer, declare it early.
Reasons a bid scores badly
These points are mostly good practice rather than rules.
- Not answering the question asked. Under the Act, award criteria must be clear, measurable and specific, and the buyer scores against its published method. Answer each part of the question in order and use the scoring guide. See writing winning quality answers.
- Qualifying or changing the buyer's terms. The winning tender must be one the buyer considers meets its requirements as described in the tender documents. Adding your own terms, caveats or exclusions risks your tender not meeting those requirements. Raise concerns through clarification questions before the deadline instead.
- Pricing errors. The Act has no rule on fixing arithmetic mistakes, so do not assume a buyer will correct them. Check totals, VAT treatment, units and that every line of the pricing schedule is filled in. See how tender prices are scored.
| Problem | Rule or good practice? | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Late or over word limit | Rule: buyer may disregard | Submit early, count words |
| Fails a condition of participation | Rule: buyer must disregard | Check every condition before you start |
| Exclusion ground applies | Rule | Declare fully, show steps taken |
| Price looks abnormally low | Rule: buyer must ask first | Keep your workings |
| Off-topic answers, pricing errors, own terms | Good practice | Follow the question and the instructions |
After the decision: assessment summaries and standstill
Assessment summaries
For above-threshold contracts awarded after a competitive tender, the buyer must give an assessment summary to every supplier whose tender was assessed, at the same time, before it publishes the contract award notice. It must include your score for each award criterion with reasons that refer to your tender, and, if you lost, the same information for the winning tender (redacted for confidentiality where needed).
You do not get one if your tender was disregarded (for example for failing a condition of participation), though the guidance says buyers should tell you in writing as soon as reasonably possible. Below-threshold contracts and call-offs under a framework do not need an assessment summary.
The standstill period
The contract award notice starts a standstill period of at least eight working days, beginning on the day the notice is published, during which the buyer cannot sign the contract. Weekends and bank holidays in any part of the UK do not count, and the notice states the last day. A legal challenge issued and notified during standstill automatically stops the contract being signed until it is resolved or a court lifts the suspension. Standstill is not required for below-threshold contracts. It is also not required for light touch contracts, call-offs under frameworks or contracts awarded through dynamic markets, though for those the buyer can choose a voluntary standstill of at least eight working days.
Asking for and using feedback
Buyers may add general feedback to an assessment summary, and the guidance says this may be particularly useful for small firms, but there is no legal duty to give it. Ask soon after the result, with specific questions: where you lost marks, and what a higher-scoring answer contained. Compare your scores with the winner's, then fix your weakest area before the next bid. See how to write a tender.
Frequently asked questions
Can a buyer accept my bid if I am a few minutes late?
Under the Act it may disregard a late tender rather than must, but it has to treat all suppliers equally. Treat the deadline as final.
Do I need the contract insurance before I bid?
No. Buyers cannot require insurance for the contract to be in place before award. They can ask for evidence you will have it from the start, and can require insurance you must hold by law, such as employers' liability.
Will I always see my scores if I lose?
Only for above-threshold contracts awarded after a competitive tender, and only if your tender was assessed. For smaller contracts, ask for feedback.
Can a contract that went wrong years ago stop me winning?
On above-threshold contracts under the Act, it can count as a discretionary exclusion ground if it ended in termination, damages or a settlement, or poor performance you did not put right. For breach of contract, the buyer must ignore events it knew (or should reasonably have known) about more than three years ago, and you can show what you have changed.
Ready to look? Browse open contracts for your trade, or get a free weekly shortlist: get free alerts.
This guide is general information, not legal advice.
Sources
- legislation.gov.uk: Procurement Act 2023, section 12 (Covered procurement: objectives) (checked 21 October 2026)
- legislation.gov.uk: Procurement Act 2023, section 19 (Award of public contracts following a competitive tendering procedure) (checked 21 October 2026)
- legislation.gov.uk: Procurement Act 2023, section 22 (Conditions of participation) (checked 21 October 2026)
- legislation.gov.uk: Procurement Act 2023, section 26 (Excluding suppliers from a competitive award) (checked 21 October 2026)
- legislation.gov.uk: Procurement Act 2023, section 30 (Excluding suppliers for improper behaviour) (checked 21 October 2026)
- legislation.gov.uk: Procurement Act 2023, section 50 (Contract award notices and assessment summaries) (checked 21 October 2026)
- legislation.gov.uk: Procurement Act 2023, section 51 (Standstill periods on the award of contracts) (checked 21 October 2026)
- legislation.gov.uk: Procurement Act 2023, section 54 (Time limits) (checked 21 October 2026)
- legislation.gov.uk: Procurement Act 2023, section 57 (Meaning of excluded and excludable supplier) (checked 21 October 2026)
- legislation.gov.uk: Procurement Act 2023, section 58 (Considering whether a supplier is excluded or excludable) (checked 21 October 2026)
- legislation.gov.uk: Procurement Act 2023, section 62 (Debarment list) (checked 21 October 2026)
- legislation.gov.uk: Procurement Act 2023, section 82 (Conflicts of interest: duty to mitigate) (checked 21 October 2026)
- legislation.gov.uk: Procurement Act 2023, section 85 (Regulated below-threshold contracts: procedure) (checked 21 October 2026)
- legislation.gov.uk: Procurement Act 2023, Schedule 6 (Mandatory exclusion grounds) (checked 21 October 2026)
- legislation.gov.uk: Procurement Act 2023, Schedule 7 (Discretionary exclusion grounds) (checked 21 October 2026)
- GOV.UK: Guidance: Assessing competitive tenders (checked 21 October 2026)
- GOV.UK: Guidance: Competitive tendering procedures (checked 21 October 2026)
- GOV.UK: Guidance: Conditions of participation (checked 21 October 2026)
- GOV.UK: Guidance: Exclusions (checked 21 October 2026)
- GOV.UK: Guidance: Debarment (checked 21 October 2026)
- GOV.UK: Guidance: Conflicts of interest (checked 21 October 2026)
- GOV.UK: Guidance: Central Digital Platform and publication of information (checked 21 October 2026)
- GOV.UK: Guidance: Assessment summaries (checked 21 October 2026)
- GOV.UK: Guidance: Contract award notices and standstill (checked 21 October 2026)
- GOV.UK: Guidance: Below-threshold contracts (checked 21 October 2026)
- GOV.UK: Guidance: Transitional and saving arrangements (checked 21 October 2026)
- GOV.UK: Guidance: Devolved contracting authorities (checked 21 October 2026)